For the past two years, I've worked in the medical tent at the Vermont 100 ultra-distance running race and often saw extensor muscle group injuries.
Compartment syndromes, shin splints and stress fractures are all associated with three muscles called the extensor muscle group. The group includes the anterior tibialis, extensor hallicus longus and extensor digitorum longus. They are located at the front of the tibia (shinbone) and originate just below the outside of the knee. They course down the front of the shin and cross toward the body's midline, just above the ankle, and then insert into the foot. The main function of this muscle group is to dorsiflex (bring the toes toward the shin) at toe-off, and to prevent foot drop during the swing phase of the gait. These three muscles and their associated tendons also stop forward motion of the lower leg at heel strike.
The tendons from these muscles lie under the retinaculum, a series of ligaments that cross the lower leg at the ankle. The retinaculum consists of the transverse and cruciate crural ligaments. Overuse and stress injuries to the underlying tendons can occur at this ligametous binding point.
Gravity's role
Every athlete's gravitational forces increase when running, causing the body to act as if it weighs more. Gravity's effect on the extensor muscle group is to increase workloads at heel strike, when the tendons are bound most tightly under the retinaculum and working hardest to brake the forward motion of the lower leg. Tendons traveling under these ligaments can become prone to stress injuries, resulting in sudden-onset tendonitis and associated painful dysfunction.
For the past two years, I've worked in the medical tent at the Vermont 100 ultra-distance running race and often saw extensor muscle group injuries. They are classic overuse injuries. By the halfway mark in the Vermont 100, intense pain from one of these injuries forced many runners to drop out.
Extensor muscle group injuries are not usually seen in shorter distance races, but can be present in hilly, short courses or when runners use hill workouts for training runs. Downhill running is the most aggravating. The tendon sheaths are literally irritated and injured by the rasping grasp of the retinaculum as the ligaments attempt to hold the tendons in place.
I have always believed that increased gravitational forces are the main cause of this problem. As a comparative example, the injury is not often seen in hikers covering long distances and carrying heavy loads. The effect of gravity on the runner can catapult the body's effective weight up to ten and even twelve times normal weight. An efficient runner may be running at two to three times his/her normal body weight, but the inefficient runner is usually above 10 times body weight. Knowing these basic facts, overuse injury becomes easy to understand. The workload is just too great. At heel strike, the body must brake the motion of the lower leg, allowing it to slowly stop moving forward while the foot gradually phases from heel strike to midstance (when it is completely on the ground).
Prevention
Taking the necessary time to allow muscles to develop and become used to an athletic activity is the most important element in injury prevention. Moving forward in a training program should be a gradual process in both time and intensity.
The old rule of not more than a 10 percent increase at a time still prevails, but deserves further explanation. Keep a log that identifies daily workouts. Review and summarize it weekly. Use your past week's mileage totals as the tool for increasing the following week's training schedules. Increase your week's mileage by no more than 10 percent.
Downhill courses can be particularly difficult on this muscle group and should be limited but not eliminated. Add them to your training course gradually. Hill training is important; both uphill and downhill workouts should be part of your training program.
Symptoms and treatment
When the injury occurs, it usually comes on rapidly. Pain will be worse at heel strike or when running downhill. Even walking downhill can be painful. Be smart and STOP; examine the area in the front of your ankle. You may find an area of tenderness when you apply pressure, which can be made worse when you move your foot up or down. Swelling may be present.
RICE: Rest, Ice Compression, Elevation are the treatments of choice for this sudden onset problem. Ice the area in the front of the ankle as soon as possible. An ace bandage may be applied and it should make the condition feel better. Elevate for the first 24 hours as much as possible. Rest is critical. Do not try to run through extensor muscle group injuries or try to return to workouts too soon. Continue to ice three to four times per day for at least 20-minutes each time, keeping your foot elevated at least to the level of your hip. Neoprene compression wraps are very helpful and can be obtained in drug stores and athletic stores. Rest from workouts should continue till there is no stiffness in the ankle. Walking down a flight of stairs is a good test that recovery is complete. If no stiffness is present, you are good to go.
- Login or register to post comments
- 3212 reads
- send to friend

User Comments
extensor muscle injury --
Hi
I just stumbled upon Rob Rinaldi's description of the extensor muscle stress/overuse injury from 2006. He described how the tendons from these muscles, (which lie under the retinaculum, a series of ligaments that cross the lower leg at the ankle) can be irritated by the binding force of the retinaculum's transverse and cruciate crural ligaments.
I have been suffering from pain in my left ankle for two years, and wonder whether this might be the correct diagnosis. Has anyone else found this diagnosis to be helpful, and do you have any suggestions for treatment?
Dr. Rinaldi, if you are still posting to this site, thanks very much for a helpful explanation. If you have any ideas you'd be willing to share about treating this condition when it becomes chronic, I would appreciate it. I am gently exercising my ankle and taking quite a bit of anti-inflammatory medications, but if I stand or walk for any length of time the pain is pretty severe.
Thanks all.
Kristian
Re: extensor injury
K----the ankle area is large and complcated with many structures. I have a few questions. How old are you? Is the pain on the inside/outside or top of your ankle? When is pain worse, after rest or with use? When and how did this start---suddenly or gradually? sorry you're hurt rob rinaldi
other relevant info
Hi Rob
I left out some important info.
1) I have had multiple tests -- xrays, catscans, podiatric surgeon exam, many orthopedic exams, and three MRIs. No objective findings except for (a) inflammation of peroneal muscles (b) slow nerve conduction across left knee.
2) No significant objective findings of disc degeneration / lumbar spine problems. I was seen by one of Seattle's top neurosurgeons, Kai Johannsen, and he positively ruled out any significant lumbar spine problems. At my request, he referred me to a neurologist who, luckily, was trained as a physiatrist. (Angeli Mayadev, M.D. Swedish Medical Center Neuroscience). She found the peroneal inflammation on my most recent MRI and diagnosed peroneal inflammation.
3) No one -- except perhaps you -- has ever been able to explain why the pain radiates from and is most constant in my left ankle -- which is why your article struck a chord. From your description I am hypothesizing that the irritation of the extensor muscle tendons (and thus the pain radiating up my left leg) is caused by constant friction between the tendons and the ligaments. This might be an overuse injury caused by my too-quick acceleration of the elliptical cardio machine at the gym.
Thanks.
Kristian
ankle injury
Hi Rob
thanks for responding. For some reason, the site didn't notify me that you had responded or i would have replied earlier.
to answer your questions
1) I am 50. The initial onset of pain was May of 2007.
2) the pain is on the anterior distal left ankle, along the retinaculum transverse ligaments, also at the crural cruciate ligaments. the pain travels up the extensor muscle, distal left leg, crosses the left knee and goes just above the knee traveling to midline of the body.
3) pain onset with walking or standing. Pain is relatively 24/7. Relieved by sitting or lying down, even for brief periods, then can walk again without pain, then pain onset repeats. Pain generally worse with time dosage (e.g., worse at night when muscles are tired), but sometimes is present as soon as I get out of bed.
4) pain came on suddenly but with no apparent trauma or incident. I had over-exercised on elliptical machine approx 6 months before onset, and went from 10 minutes / night to 1 hour / night, 6 nights a week. Did not follow nor aware of 10% increase rule you mention. However, had largely discontinued exercise prior to onset May 2007.
I was not informed of the RICE treatment, and have had to continue to walk since May 2007, which has probably not helped. I currently practice walking per the book Chi-Walking (think this is basically the power walking model). I take multiple inflammatories (500 mg of naproxen sodium a day).
I really appreciate your advice. Thanks much, Rob.
If you can email directly to kristiankofoed9@gmail.com that would be great.
Kristian Kofoed